Need a sweet way to celebrate? Our custom cookie cakes are soft, chewy, and totally party ready! Perfect for birthdays, graduations, thank-yous, or just because. Each cake is made fresh to order in our Pittsburgh kitchen and can be personalized with your message, colors, and favorite flavors.

We recommend booking your cookie cake orders at least 2 weeks in advance. Dates fill quickly during holidays and event seasons, so the earlier, the better! We’ll always try to accommodate if our schedule allows.

If you need an order in under two weeks, please email us at orders@benignisbakery.com

Cookie Cake Options & Pricing

Custom Order Request

  • 10-Inch Cookie Cake – $25

    Our most popular size! Serves approx. 10-12. Includes buttercream piping and a short custom message—great for birthdays, team celebrations, or gifting.

  • 10-Inch Double Layer Cookie Cake – $40

    Serves approx. 12-16, depending on the size of the slices. Includes buttercream piping and a short custom message—great for birthdays, team celebrations, or gifting.

  • Half Sheet Cookie Cake – $60

    Serves approx. 20 to 30, depending on the size of slices. Includes themed buttercream details and longer custom messages.


    Perfect for big parties or showers!

  • Double Half Sheet Cookie Cake - $90

    When you're feeding a crowd. Serves 45-60. Includes detailed buttercream decoration and fully customizable message.

    Great for larger events or office parties.

1 4
Custom Order Request

Cookie Cake Details

Custom Order Request

  • What's Included:

    1. Super soft and chewy cookie cake
    2. Custom buttercream border
    3. Short message or name
    4. Packaged in a bakery tray, ready to gift or serve

  • Flavor Options

    Choose from our tried-and-true favorites:

    • Chocolate Chip (The Classic)
    • Birthday Cake (White chocolate + sprinkles)
    • Cookies & Cream
    • Double Chocolate Chip (Chocolate base)
    • Seasonal Flavor (Ask what's available!)

    Custom flavors may be available upon request!

1 2
Custom Order Request