Welcome to Benigni’s Bakery—where every cookie has a story.

Home-baked with love, inspired by family traditions and made fresh in Pittsburgh.

All of our products are made from scratch in small batches, using real ingredients, a whole lot of care, and just the right amount of butter. Whether you’re celebrating something big or just treating yourself to something cozy, we’ve got something for every moment.

Our Story

One of my favorite memories is pulling a chair next to my mom at the kitchen counter—elbows dusted in flour, eyes wide, learning how to bake.

That’s where this journey really began. My mom taught me that baking is how we celebrate birthdays, put the magic in holidays, show up for our friends, and make even the smallest moments feel special.

I’m proud to carry on those kitchen counter memories and to share them with you, one small batch at a time.

Our Values

  • Small-Batch, Always Fresh

    Every order is baked just for you! Never frozen, never mass-produced. Just fresh, delicious cookies made with care from start to finish.

  • Tradition & Heart

    Inspired by the memories of baking with my mom, every recipe carries a little love, a little legacy, and a whole lot of heart.

  • Celebrating Moments

    From birthdays to “just because,” our cookies are made to bring magic to those moments. Thoughtful, joyful, and always shared.

1 3

Let’s be friends.