Mixed Cookie Tray

Requests welcome! To customize this tray with any of our classic and deluxe flavors, please fill out this form. If this form is not filled out, you will receive a mix of cookies. 

Reminder: All cookie trays are made fresh to order in our kitchen. As a preorder-only bakery, we kindly ask for 1-2 weeks notice before your requested pickup date. Need something sooner? Feel free to reach out—we’ll do our best to accommodate!

5 dozen tray includes: 3 dozen classic cookies and 2 dozen deluxe cookies.

10 dozen tray includes: 6 dozen classic cookies and 4 dozen deluxe cookies.

Classic cookies may include: 

• Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Snickerdoodle, Confetti, Double Chocolate Chip
• Seasonal flavors may be available. Feel free to contact us at Orders@benignisbakery.com

Deluxe cookies may include: 

• S'mores, Berry Jam Thumbprints, Peanut Butter Cup, Cookie & Cream, Mocha Chip 
• Seasonal flavors may be available; feel free to ask in the custom form.

Local pickup only. You’ll receive a follow-up email after purchase to confirm your pickup date and any preferences.

Packaged on a sturdy serving tray.