Welcome to Benigni’s Bakery—where every cookie has a story.
All of our products are made from scratch in small batches, using real ingredients, a whole lot of care, and just the right amount of butter. Whether you’re celebrating something big or just treating yourself to something cozy, we’ve got something for every moment.
Please Note: As a made-to-order bakery, we kindly ask for 3-4 days’ notice for most basic items and 2 weeks for custom decorated cookies and cookie trays.
We take a limited number of orders each week to ensure everything is baked fresh and with care —so the earlier you book, the better!
Need something sooner? Send us a message—we’ll always do our best to make it happen if our schedule allows!
Custom orders only
Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies - Starting at $50
Hand-iced cookies made just for your event or celebration. Choose from three tiers of detail and submit a custom request.
Custom Orders only
Custom Cookie Cakes - Starting at $30
Your favorite cookie, party-sized! Available in four sizes with personalized messages and buttercream accents.
Double Layer Option Available! Love extra frosting and a taller cake? Our 10-inch and half sheet cookie cakes can be upgraded to a double layer with a buttercream filling between the cookies.
Classic Flavors
Classic Cookies – By the Dozen - $14
Soft, nostalgic, and baked fresh to order. Available in timeless flavors like chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, and peanut butter.
Deluxe Flavors
Deluxe Cookies – By the Dozen - $24
Thick, chewy, bakery-style cookies packed with mix-ins and flavor. Think s’mores, cookies & cream, and birthday cake.
perfect for any event
Cookie Trays
Crowd-pleasing trays in Classic, Deluxe, or Mixed varieties. A beautiful (and delicious) addition to any party, event, or cookie table.
Cookie trays sizes include 5 or 10 dozen options.
Need help choosing the right treat for your event? We’re happy to help.
📧 Email us at hello@benignisbakery or fill out our contact form.